Comcast- on and off service still going on

Submitted by fcui21 on Wed, 02/28/2007 - 8:17pm.

Anyone else in the Dumfries/Montclair area experiencing intermittent downtime/outages on your Comcast Cable TV or High speed internet service? This has been going on since September of 2006; I have complained several times to several managers but they continue to blame it on the "upgrade project" that's been going on for over 5 months. On top of that, we never get any written notices letting us know that there would be service interruption. Please let me know if anyone else is having this problem. I have already filed a BBB complaint against them. If I must, I will start a petition so we can kick Comcast to the curb and get someone reliable in the area like Verizon or Cox. Let me know your thoughts. -FC

Submitted by Chris Casey on Wed, 02/28/2007 - 8:28pm.

When we became frustrated with Comcast over their change of lineup (they dropped WGN denying us Cubs games!), we took our business elsewhere, first to Dish and then to DirectTV when I learned they were the better choice for catching all the baseball games that money could buy.

We kept Comcast only for our Internet access, and that service has been fine with only infrequent outages. But since switching to satellite for television, we've never looked back.

Submitted by Mike on Wed, 02/28/2007 - 9:59pm.

Cept I went from DirecTv to Dish because initially DirecTV wanted over $1000 to upgrade 4 receivers to HD. Comcast Internet was flaky for a while last year, but recently all has been well.

I share the wealth, Vonage, Comcast, Dish, TMobile... everyone gets a piece of my paycheck!

I think if I was a new subscriber I would look close at Verizon and their Phone/TV/Internet package. Many are getting fiber to the house, not sure if that is happening in our area though.

Submitted by Enchanted Light... on Thu, 03/01/2007 - 2:22am.

We've also been having a lot of problems since September and have called numerous times, had techs come out to "fix" the service, etc. We did have a small piece of line in our yard that was bad that they dug up and fixed but even after that, there have been so many issues.

The thing is that they always immediately tell us it's our fault yet the problem will miraculously fix itself by the next day. And there have been at least 3 (I think 4) times where we've had someone scheduled to come out and they didn't show! And then when I call to complain they say they canceled the appointment because service was back. Yet they don't call to tell us so we have to take time off to be sure someone was here! SO dang frustrating! And they owe us about $180 in lost time right now that they still haven't paid even though they said they were crediting our account.

The latest was on 2/26/07 when our service suddenly went down and I was on with a tech for over an hour troubleshooting. The IP address couldn't renew itself. So after a lot of testing, he said it must be the modem and we'd have to buy a new one. So off to CompUSA we went, and $80 later we had a new modem. Hooked it up and it managed to get online enough to let us download Comcast's install software. Couldn't get past the reboot and connect part. So I called again. They told us it was our signal and we'd have to schedule someone to come out...but couldn't get an appointment for 2 days. Even a stupid supervisor (who was a bit surly) wouldn't upgrade us even after all the problems and complaints we'd had in the past.

SO...about 4:40 am on the 27th, it came back and was fine. So I called late on the evening of the 27th to cancel our appointment and the tech that I spoke to said that it was actually a weird error their servers were having where instead of renewing the IP addresses every 5 days like it's supposed to, it was renewing them EVERY SECOND!! So that's why the computers couldn't hold onto an IP address because it was repeatedly being reset. Now, here's the rub. The techs that I spoke to the night of the issue were from the Silver Spring office. Apparently, the notice about the problem never got to that call center! So anyone who talked to that center got the run around! Everyone else got the mass mailing but the head folks at the Silver Spring call center never forwarded it to their tech department. The idiots! So almost 3 hours on the phone and $80 later...ARGH!

If we could get line of sight for satellite, we'd be ditching Comcast right now. I'm SO ready to file a complaint with PW County about these jerks. If they'd quit telling me every issue was my fault and just tell the truth and give me an approximate time of when it might be up, I'd be fine with that because I know that things can go wrong. But when they automatically blame the customer, it's just ridiculous! I'm completely OVER it! Somewhere I have the email address and phone number for the CEO. I'm about ready to publish it so that all the PO'd customers can give him a piece of their minds!

I'd love to set up some kind of phone tree or something that would allow folks in the neighborhood to contact one another when stuff goes down so that we can figure out if it's just our house or the street or the whole neighborhood. In fact, I was considering stuffing the notice boxes under our mailboxes on my street with flyers proposing just that!

Any takers on the upper end in the Spring Branch area?

Submitted by thebyrd on Thu, 03/01/2007 - 9:27am.

I have to say that my personal e-mail webserver went down yesterday.. due to my ip address being changed (it has been the same one for 2 years). I changed it this morning in my DNS settings... but it might take 8 hrs for the DNS to update all over the major hubs and let me have my e-mail server/web server back up. Minor nuisance compared to service.

I guess I must be one of the lucky ones. I have had comcast cable since May 2001. I live in Southlake Cove diagonal from Dairy Queen. About 4 months or so ago.. we had problems with comcast internet going out and saw a couple of comcast vans in the neighborhood. I will say that after that week, my download speeds are much faster than our T1 line at work. I can download a 10mb file in 10 seconds. I think when I clocked it... I was getting 1.2mb/sec down and 725kb/sec up. This is incredible to say the least. Start that petition, I'll be on the other side of the street trying to keep comcast internet on this end of the neighborhood. This has also provided an even better signal for my Vonage connected home. My phone bill since December 2003 has only been 28.62 (until 2 months ago.. it went up another 1.00). We enjoy free long distance, call-waiting, caller-i.d., voice-mail, 3-way.. basically everything that verizon charged us $88.00+ / month.

As far as their cable line-up... we only use their internet for a reason. We switched to Directv and never looked back. I have 4 tivo boxes that I hacked and upgraded to 200+ hrs and an HD box from directv.(i would be happy to help anyone else upgrade) The only time Directv has been interrupted was during really bad torrential downpours.. and then it was only for a limited time.

I can say that I honestly believe the interruptions are due to upgrades and really hope that it gets cleared up for you immediately.

Part of the problems could be attributed to the Comcast Software. Way too much overhead.. but that is just my opinion. We bought the Surfboard 2 by motorola... as suggested by the tier 3 tech. I never speak or waste my time with tier 1 or 2 when troubleshooting any tech problems... I let them know that I've done all of the basic troubleshooting and will not be satisfied until I speak to tier 3 rep.. and that I'll know if they are NOT a tier 3. The tier 1 folks are sometimes great.. but also sometimes feel like they are reading from a manual.

Submitted by jasonk on Thu, 03/01/2007 - 2:50pm.

What in the world are you doing running a web/mail server off a cable modem connection in the first place?? Some people have too much time on their hands. ;)

I just wanted to add that:

1) My cable modem service with Comcast has been flawless for three years. I wouldn't touch it ever. I suspect if you're having internet trouble it is more likely to be an issue on your own computer, not with the cable service. Unfortunately harder for anybody to troubleshoot.

2) Tech support at Comcast is the same as any other big company (Verizon, etc;) and has the same problems. Appointment issues, wasting time talking to people who can't help you, etc; Its a matter of cutting through the nonsense and getting somebody out who CAN help.

3) In some of these cases where you feel you are getting the runaround I would highly recommend insisting that they send somebody out and not waste your time with the phone techs' "solutions" that you already know won't work.

4) And lastly, has anybody looked at what we're getting from Comcast in March after this upgrade? The triple play deal includes phone service (I am more than ready to dump Verizon), 10 mbps cable modem (we've been getting like 6 mbps to date), and a greatly expanded cable lineup including all the premier movie channels. The price is $160 which is only about $10 more than I currently pay them for far less: HBO only and internet, no phone.

I spoke with Comcast last week and you can lock in that price for like two years - similar to the agreement you make with a cell phone provider.

Anyway not to shill for Comcast but I was pretty excited about the new deal. I'm not eager to go the dish route. And they pretty much had me with the addition of Fox Soccer Channel. I may never leave my couch.

Submitted by jasonk on Thu, 03/01/2007 - 2:52pm.

btw Hopefully you did this, but if you set the TTL as low as possible (like 300) in your DNS settings, your DNS change should propogate in a lot less than eight hours. Good luck with it though.

Submitted by thebyrd on Thu, 03/01/2007 - 4:27pm.

Took 2 hrs after I made the change at http://www.easydns.com/ I don't know what the TTL setting is currently at, but as long as comcast doesn't change my ip address again.. I should be alright. I used to have a 68.??.??.?? number .. now i'm on a 71.??.??.?? number. You can get your own ip address by typing http://www.whatismyip.com/ in case you are behind a router with NAT enabled.

Submitted by dburke-fonda on Thu, 03/15/2007 - 7:30am.

I believe today is the day for the new, upgraded television lineup. Maybe that is why my internet connection is down... Is anyone else having troubles with their Comcast internet connection today? But then, if you are, you might not be able to read this message!

Submitted by Mike on Thu, 03/15/2007 - 7:56am.

Im ok this morning - down by Northgate & Waterway - actually my service with comcast has been really good for the last few months. I get Dish Satellite TV so perhaps I am not affected.

Submitted by dburke-fonda on Thu, 03/15/2007 - 11:38am.

I'm located on Edgehill Drive. My cable modem was blinking orange this morning, indicating that the internet service was not coming over the cable line. I unplugged the modem and plugged it back in, hoping that this would reset things on my end. But no luck...this may or may not be due to the service upgrade on the digital TV channels. Thanks for your response!

Submitted by jasonk on Thu, 03/15/2007 - 12:55pm.

I actually called Comcast this morning to get the new upgraded service. The rep said it would be available "any day now". So I guess the 15th wasn't a hard and fast date. Seems kind of strange that they advertised it though.

Submitted by Julezand3 on Thu, 03/15/2007 - 8:12pm.

Cable has been intermittent since 27 Feb(3 problem calls) Had a comcast tech show up this evening on Olivia Way. cable light on modem had been out (blinking) all day, but then magically came on right before the tech arrived. Tech said upgrades would be on going for about a month "Nothing I can do". Looks like I'll be calling comcast to credit my account. Their network control center can tell exactly how long the modem has been off line. Might have to look at going with verizon if this doesn't clear soon.

Submitted by Julezand3 on Mon, 03/26/2007 - 7:36pm.

1 month and 4 techs later.....Modem swap-out was the problem. old Hayes terayon modems apparently can't handle the recent upgrade. wish the other 3 techs new that.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.